Who is a citizen? The Founders left us a riddle

by Jonathan Turley

USA Today
September 14, 2010

The raging debate over illegal immigration has grown on a steady diet of rhetoric and recrimination. However, beneath all the hyperbole is a long-standing and unresolved debate over what it means to be a citizen. It turns out that the most foundational right contained in the Constitution — citizenship itself — is poorly defined and even more poorly understood.

There has long been a conscious avoidance of the question over so-called birthright citizenship — citizenship claimed by the children of illegal aliens. Indeed, the question has become increasingly difficult to address as the numbers of birthright citizens grow each year. In 2008, one in 12 babies in this country was born to illegal immigrants — 8% of all births. This is not counting the millions of prior such births, often referred to by critics as "anchor babies." With any change in the definition of citizenship assuring tremendous social changes and upheaval, the question has been left unresolved for more than two centuries.

More